Is ChatGPT a Therapist?

Is ChatGPT a Therapist?

ChatGPT Is Our Go-To for Answers — But Is It Worth Discussing Them with a Human? 

For many, ChatGPT has become the place we go to for support, and answers. And why not? It gives us quick responses, often at the very moment we need them most, and has access to enormous amounts of information at our fingertips. In fact, I heard a compelling piece on the CBC about a man who said ChatGPT saved his life after his wife left him.

Feeling confused about a relationship? Looking for ways to manage anxiety? Unsure how to approach a difficult conversation? All you have to do is pick up your phone, type your question, and boom — you have an answer. 

ChatGPT and other AI tools have also become a source of emotional support for many people. They can help us put our thoughts into words, explore different perspectives, and find information that might otherwise feel difficult to access. 

But here’s something worth thinking about: Can an answer understand the complexity of your unique situation, or does it simply respond to the question you ask? 

Let’s take a simple example. 

Me: Hey, ChatGPT! Tell me how to practice boundaries with my partner. 

ChatGPT: Start by identifying your needs, communicating them clearly, learning to say no, and staying consistent with your boundaries. 

Me: Okay, but I’m still confused. What if I say no to my partner and they get angry? What if I feel guilty afterwards? What if setting a boundary creates conflict in my relationship? 

And this is where things become more complicated than a list of suggestions. 

Knowing that we need boundaries is one thing. Actually setting them, especially when we fear disappointing someone, triggering conflict, or damaging a relationship, is another. 

This is where human interaction can make a meaningful difference. 

A therapist might ask: What has happened in the past when you tried to express your needs? What feels most difficult in your relationship right now? How long have you been experiencing this? What emotions come up when conflict begins? 

Rather than simply repeating the advice to set boundaries, a therapist can help you explore what makes it difficult to put that advice into practice. Together, you might identify a small, realistic step, practice how to communicate with it, and consider how to respond if the conversation becomes uncomfortable. 

And the conversation doesn’t necessarily end there. 

When you return for your next session, you can reflect on what happened when you tried the approach. What worked? What didn’t? What feelings came up? What might you want to do differently next time? 

Over time, this process can help you build on what you’ve learned and apply it more confidently in your everyday life. 

A therapist’s role is not simply to provide information. It also involves asking follow-up questions, exploring inconsistencies, gently challenging assumptions, and helping you consider perspectives you may not have thought about. The therapeutic relationship creates the safety to work through difficult experiences with someone who can respond to you, emotionally support you and help you create a tailored approach to your problem.

Of course, this doesn’t mean that ChatGPT is not useful. It can be a helpful starting point for reflection, learning, and preparing for difficult conversations. It may even help you identify questions you want to explore with someone else. 

However, AI-generated information should not automatically be treated as accurate or appropriate for every situation. An answer that sounds convincing may not capture the full context of your experience. In fact – the man on the radio admitted to going to over 30 therapy sessions, in addition to speaking with ChatGPT when his therapist wasn’t available.

Perhaps the real question isn’t whether we should turn to ChatGPT or to another human. It’s whether we can use what we learn from AI as a starting point for deeper understanding, meaningful conversations, and real-life change. 

Because sometimes, we don’t just need an answer. We need the opportunity to explore what that answer means for us, in our own lives and relationships. 

And that is something worth making space for.